Pinterest is the “Tinder” of design dating apps. You think you have what you need and love, something that checks most of your boxes, and then you’re scrolling and you see a new shiny (literally) thing that makes you wonder if it could be even better. I finally have a tiny bit of brain space (and I do mean tiny) to start back into the guest cottage design process, namely the bathroom that has been at a standstill awaiting my flooring decision. I had it all locked in- thin-set brick in a herringbone pattern. I sampled a ton, made my decision, and ordered a box. I was about to order the rest, but as the wood on the walls went in, I realized that this bathroom is going to lean VERY rustic, with a lot of dark reddish tones on all walls, ceilings, AND the floor. And while I like rustic in theory, and nothing is wrong with leaning into a vibe, I had second thoughts that turned into a U-turn. Are we missing an opportunity to do something spectacular and extra beautiful??? I know that the brick will look good, but could something else look even better?

I wrote about wanting a higher-gloss tile finish to contrast against all the rustic texture a couple of weeks ago when two commenters warned me not to do it. And I listened. One said they were in the middle of tearing out their high-gloss tile as we speak. OOF. Now I have a feeling the tile is a large-scale 12×24 porcelain situation that a lot of builders put in (because it’s affordable to buy and install) and it’s 100% too slippery for a floor. When I took to Reddit, this was the case – all big-format tile complaints. Sure, the polished high-gloss doesn’t help, but I wonder if it’s more the lack of texture on the tile or grout lines that makes it specifically slippery. Ceramic tile doesn’t come that big, but if it did, I wonder if it would be almost as slippery. So let’s go through the pros and cons of bathroom tile flooring, what we are considering, and then I’d LOVE to hear any warnings about high-gloss tile.

Look how good it was going to look. I chose this for 3 main reasons.
But as I was finally ready to make the decision, I really thought about the cons of this as flooring:
While it’s not totally off the table, I’m starting to see all these gorgeous high-gloss tile floors in kitchens and bathrooms, and while I know intellectually that it’s not recommended, I just think contrasting off the reclaimed wood on the walls would be STUNNING.
And then Karen and Kim in the comments reminded me of the slippery factor, and I don’t like tile regrets. And while I think most people would be fine, the facts are that this bathroom is a portal from the backyard into the game room, with kids in the summer on the grass with wet feet flying through to go to the bathroom or play Pop-a-Shot. And then if and when anybody who was older were to live here, I would worry about it as well.
But then there are a lot of things that are “against the rules” when really it’s not that big of a deal. Unlacquered brass plumbing is one of them (the patina can go to tarnish really quickly if you don’t take care of it). Real wood kitchen islands are another (we have a lot of wear and tear on ours and I have zero regrets). TV above a fireplace is so controversial (but I’ve done it and love it!). Now neither of these things are “dangerous,” but I also wondered if having enough grout lines and a slight texture would solve this particular problem.

I used 2×2 high gloss tile flooring in our kids’ bathroom at the mountain house, and it was never slippery. In fact, you would think that it would be hard on your feet since zellige can be irregular, but we didn’t notice anything at all. Zero regrets.


Here we used a 1×2 herringbone, high gloss on mesh sheets, and zero slip issues. This is likely because of the amount of grout lines that inhibit slippage. The vintage rug also helps. But this guest cottage bathroom is big, and so I love the idea of scaling up the tile a little bit more (this just feels too small to me).

Now this is the scale I was thinking for the guest cottage bathroom, but not matte. This tile works so great because it is the Pratt and Larsen brownstone finish that inherently has a lot of texture PLUS, there are still grout lines. While I’m sure that if we had water all over the tile and someone was running barefoot from the outside, they could slip. For the most part, we’ve had zero issues with this.


This bathroom was bigger, with more floor space, so I liked the idea of scaling up. I LOVE this choice for in here and would do it again in this same vibe for sure. The natural stone texture made it inherently non-slip even though it was large-scale, with few grout lines. I suppose I could consider this – definitely softer on the foot than brick…like a little boring and safe, but worth exploring. But no, it’s just too harsh and dark for this vibe.

Here we really lived on the edge of danger by installing a polished stone slab, cut into 12″ square “tiles”. Y’all, ZERO SLIPPAGE. Why? Bath mat (not shown, lol). And in the guest cottage I will have a vintage runner near the door, then a smaller rug between the sink and the water closet (and a bath mat outside the shower). So maybe rugs are the answer?


As I was writing this post, I was like, “wait, what did we put in Ken’s bathroom?” and with a quick Google search I was reminded that I DID use a 12×24 honed marble tile on their bathroom floor, outside of the tub/shower area. I texted them asking about it and got this immediately in return: “It’s great! Not slippery. No problems at all”. So large scale is fine if matte, high-gloss tile in small scale is fine, but what about in the middle??

I love the scale of the mudroom tile (and the border), which made me wonder if we did the same scale, but just with a slight sheen to it (doesn’t have to be high gloss), something to contrast with the rustic walls and pop off in a cool way…could that work? So this one is more of a crowdsourcing situation. As a reminder:
It’s not like my heart is so set on high-gloss tile that I’m willing to endanger the children or seniors in my life, but I also don’t want to make decisions based on a couple of anecdotal stories with the extreme examples that I found on the internet (i.e., 12×24 porcelain sheet tile). At the same time, I also REALLY, REALLY, REALLY don’t like taking risks with tile because it’s one of the most permanent fixtures in your house, so once these go in, they are not coming out in my lifetime. I have that mantra “simple but special” for permanent fixtures (tile, flooring, plumbing, millwork), which I said so often one year that it became a drinking game, but it’s true – and I love the hell out of all of my tile choices (the only regret was the cement tile on the floor – DON’T DO IT INSIDE).


Yesterday I popped into Ann Sacks and asked them about floor tile, and they agreed with me that it’s mostly about grout lines. They showed me a tile finish, Provencal, that we LOVED. It’s shown in the lighter blue above. It’s actually on the less expensive side and has a slightly imperfect texture that I think works really well with the old-world vibe of the house, but we can get in a lot of colors (I’m obsessed with that blue on the right).

So now I’m leaning towards the texture on the left (in a 3×8 herringbone + border) in the color on the right. Add some rugs, and I think we are safe.
But please, sound off here if you have experience with really slippery tile floors. If so, and you have a second, attach a photo to the comment so we can see what to avoid. I need to know if it’s a design urban legend (like the importance of the “kitchen triangle,” which is all just actually a preference), or if it’s mostly just these high-gloss 12×24 large format tiles, OR if putting in a 3×8 texture semi-gloss herringbone floor would work. Per my book, I do love a design rule, but I also really, really, really like breaking them if I do it thoughtfully and intentionally. They can pay off, but the risks can be so high…
Opening Image Credit: Photo by Kaitlin Green